6. Discuss the relevance of Taylor and Fayol’s contribution in the contemporary business environment.
Solution:
Both Fayol and Taylor have given principles of management of improve efficiency of an organisation by providing guidelines to the managers in taking actions and decisions. As these principles are based on the human behaviour, so, they help in establishing a relationship between the human and behaviour, so, they help in establishing a relationship between the human and materialistic resources in an organisation. Both the principles suggested division of work and specialization which focused on maximising the efficiency.Taylor gave us scientific principles of management which are being adopted by all the organisations to improve their productivity at the shop floor level the principles help in giving effective results. In the same manner, Henry Fayol gave general principles of management which when implemented at any of the levels—top, middle or lower and help in achieving better co-ordination, remove ambiguity and encourage the employees to improve their work performance.
7. 'Bhasin’ limited was engaged in the business of food processing and selling its products under a popular brand. Lately the business was expanding due to good quality and reasonable prices. Also with more people working the market for processed food was increasing. New players were also coming to cash in on the new trend. In order to keep its market share in the short run the company directed its existing workforce to work overtime. But this resulted in many problems. Due to increased pressure of work the efficiency of the workers declined. Sometimes the subordinates had to work for more than one superior resulting in declining efficiency. The divisions that were previously working on one product were also made to work on two or more products.
This resulted in a lot of overlapping and wastage. The workers were becoming indisciplined. The spirit of teamwork, which had characterized the company, previously was beginning to wane. Workers were feeling cheated and initiative was declining. The quality of the products was beginning to decline and market share was on the verge of decrease. Actually the company had implemented changes without creating the required infrastructure.
a. Identify the Principles of Management (out of 14 given by Henry Fayol) that were being violated by the company.
Solution:
The principles of management that are being violated in the given situation are as follows:
(i) Quote 1: Sometimes the subordinates had to work for more than one superior resulting in declining efficiency.
Principle: Unity of command— This is visible from the situation that the employees are made to work for more than one superior.
(ii) Quote 2: The divisions that were previously working on one product were also made to work on two or more products.
Principle: Division of work— In the situation given, One division is made to work on more than one product which gives rise to the wastages.
(iii) Quote 3: The workers were becoming indisciplined.
Principle: Discipline— ‘Principle of discipline’ is not being followed in the given situation, as workers were becoming indisciplined.
(iv) Quote 4: The spirit of teamwork, which had characterised the company, previously was beginning to wane.
Principle: Espirit de corps—As the workers lost the spirit of team work. It resulted to the violation of ‘E sprit de corps” principle.
(v) Quote 5: Workers were feeling cheated and initiative was declining.
Principle Initiative: It is given in the situation that initiative is declining and employees are discouraged.
b. Explain these principles in brief.
Solution:
(i) Unity of Command: According to this principle, subordinate should be answerable to and take orders from only one boss. If an employee gets orders from more than one superior, the employee will be confused about whose orders to follow, which will eventually affect the work. It might also cause a conflict of interests and egos among the superiors.
(ii) Division of work: Division of work means that the given task is divided into small groups or units so that the task would be completed in a competent manner. This principle results in specialisation in work.
(iii) Discipline: Discipline means that the organisation must follow the rules and regulations to ensure conformity to the set rules and policies. It is important for both the workers as well as the management to honour their commitments.
(iv) Espirit de corps: This principle states that employees should work in unity with each other. They should work like a team and team spirit should be promoted by the manager. Each employee should have a sense of belongingness. This proves functional especially in large organisations where without team work, achievement of objectives would become difficult. Team sprit helps in increasing coordination and mutual understanding among the employees and thereby improves efficiency.
(v) Initiative: According to this principle, workers should be given praiseworthy motivation and incentive to work. They should be welcomed to come up with the suggestions regarding the work. Although initiatives should be encouraged, but they should be in line with the practices and rules of the organisation. For example, the managers can ask the workers for their inputs over how to increase efficiency. Also, good suggestions can be rewarded.
c. What steps should the company management take in relation to the above principles to restore the company to its past glory?
Solution:
The steps that can be taken by the company to restore its past glory are as follows:
Scientific management must be followed.
The subordinates get instruction from only one superior at a time to avoid any confusion and chaos.
There must be specialisation in work in such a manner that each division specialises in single particular task. Hence it will help to avoid overlapping in work.
Workers must be given proper incentives and motivation to work through such measures as differential piece wage system so they can work with their full efficiency.
Preverence would be given to team work with proper coordination and understanding.
8. (Further information related to the above question 6) The management of company Bhasin Limited now realised its folly. In order to rectify the situation it appointed a management consultant -Mukti Consultants - to recommend a restructure plan to bring the company back on the rails. Mukti Consultants undertook a study of the production process at the plant of the company Bhasin Limited and recommended the following changes —
- The company should introduce scientific management with regard to production.
- Production Planning including routing, scheduling, dispatching and feedback should be implemented.
- In order to separate planning from operational management ’Functional foremanship’ should be introduced.
- ‘Work study’ should be undertaken to optimise the use of resources.
- ‘Standardisation’ of all activities should be implemented to increase efficiency and accountability.
To motivate the workers ‘Differential Piece Rate System’ should be implemented. (The above changes should be introduced apart from the steps recommended as an answer to Part c - case problem 6 above.)
It was expected that the changes will bring about a radical transformation in the working of the company and it will regain its pristine glory.
a. Do you think that introduction of scientific management as recommended by M consultants will result in intended outcome?
b. What precautions should the company undertake to implement the changes?
c. Give your answer with regard to each technique separately as enunciated in points 1 through 6 in the case problem.
Solution:
Yes, the scientific management techniques as suggested by ‘Mukti Consultants’ would be helpful for the organisation. By implementing the scientific management techniques the company would be able to work efficiently according to the standardised techniques and tools which results to improve both the quantity as well as the quality of the product. Simultaneously, It would also help in reducing the costs. In this way, scientific management would help in improving the effectiveness as well as efficiency in the work.
The following precautions can be taken by the Bhasin Limited:
(i) New staff i.e., freshly trained and specialised can be recruited for certain specific areas and the existing staff can be given proper training.
(ii) There should be proper planning of production with utmost care.
(iii) In the functional foremanship, there must be enough incentive and motivation for the employees.
(iv) Other studies such as method study, motion study, time study and fatigue study should be undertaken besides work study.
(v) For different aspects of production technique of standardisation can be used.
(vi) Monetary incentives can be given to motivate the employees to work more and with better efficiency.